top of page
Search
  • snitzoid

Biden pays off Tesla to help build out EV charging network. If you can't beat em join em.

Tesla Has Won the EV-Charger Wars

GM’s decision to follow Ford in joining Tesla’s network paves the way for a single, open U.S. electric-vehicle charging standard

By Stephen Wilmot, WSJ

June 9, 2023 10:45 am ET


Tesla’s TSLA 4.06%increase; green up pointing triangle apparent triumph in the battle of the electric-vehicle chargers is good for everyone—almost.


Shares in Tesla jumped 5% at the open Friday after General Motors GM 1.06%increase; green up pointing triangle said late Thursday that it would follow Ford F 1.18%increase; green up pointing triangle in adopting Tesla’s charging standard on its next generation of EVs. In exchange, GM’s customers will be able to recharge their vehicles on Tesla’s Supercharger network, starting next year. GM’s stock rose 4%.


The roughly $40 billion gain in Tesla’s market value seems extreme for providing what is likely to be a low-margin service, but the market reactions make sense directionally: This is a win-win situation. Tesla’s network capacity will be more fully utilized as a result of Ford and now GM joining it, while the Detroit companies have taken a major step toward addressing range anxiety for their potential EV customers. This is still a barrier to the technology’s adoption.


The losers are independent charging networks, which might not get as much traffic once they face competition from Tesla’s network. Longer term, they may even come under pressure to shift their systems to Tesla’s standard, which could be expensive.


Shares in fast-charging network EVgo and slow-charging leader ChargePoint were down about 11% in early trading. Both companies went public via special-purpose acquisition companies during the pandemic stock-trading boom and, like most former SPACs, haven’t served investors well despite a powerful operational tailwind from the Biden administration, which is funneling billions of dollars into EVs, including $7.5 billion into chargers specifically.




Tesla uses a different charging plug than the independent providers. The competition between the two standards echoes previous battles over new technologies, such as between VHS and Betamax for videotapes or narrow-gauge and wide-gauge railways in Victorian England.


With Ford and now GM on board, Tesla seems to have all but won this one in the U.S. Its victory reflects both the higher number of chargers it offers and a more seamless and reliable charging experience. On the other side lay something of a tragedy of the commons, with nobody taking full responsibility for quality control or providing a comprehensive solution.


A shakeout among independent charging companies is widely expected, and Tesla’s deals with Detroit may be a catalyst. Oil-and-gas companies that run old-fashioned service stations have been among the most aggressive consolidators so far: Shell bought Volta, another former SPAC, in March.


For most of the nascent EV industry, the emergence of a single, open standard for U.S. charging would be very welcome. There is a way to go yet, but the destination now seems clearer—and drivers can relax a bit about their battery charge.


White House is trying to persuade Tesla to keep the US's EV charging standard alive

Tesla's own charging standard for EVs is welcome, the US government says, as long as it co-exists with the US's combined charging system


By Ananya Bhattacharya, Quartz Media

Published2 hours ago


The Biden administration is opening up federal subsidies to Tesla charging stations—but only if they carry US’s own fast-charging standard for electric vehicles.


On Friday (June 9), the White House said that EV charging stations using Tesla’s standard plugs—the North American Charging Standard (NACS), as Tesla christened it last year—would be eligible for billions of dollars in federal subsidies. But they must include the “combined charging system” (CCS) to qualify.


Tesla’s charging ports are so rapidly becoming the norm, as legacy carmarkers like Ford and GM embrace it, that US government is unable to resist its ubiquity. The White House’s announcement marks the first time the administration has explicitly included Tesla in its $7.5 billion plan to build new, high-speed charging stations on 7,500 miles of the nation’s busiest highways.


“Public funding must continue to go towards open standards, which is always better for the consumer,” a displeased CharIN North America—an industry body that promotes CCS—had said after Ford became the first major US automaker to jump on the Tesla charger bandwagon last month. “Public EV infrastructure funding...should continue to only be approved for CCS-standard-enabled chargers per federal minimum standards guidance.”


Quotable: White House brings Tesla into its EV charging plans for the first time

“Earlier this year, we developed minimum standards to ensure publicly funded EV charging is accessible, reliable, and affordable for all drivers, and we required interoperability to promote competition. Those standards give flexibility for adding both CCS and NACS, as long as drivers can count on a minimum of CCS.”


—White House spokesperson Robyn Patterson, in statement to Reuters


A brief history of the growing presence of Tesla Superchargers

2012: There is no industry standard when Tesla debuts on the scene, so it develops its own charging plug for its EVs.


November 2022: Musk releases the NACS design and extends an invitation to rival manufacturers to build EVs using Tesla’s charging port. The White House cheers the move but makes no announcements about Tesla’s role in its charging infrastructure plans.


February 2022: Tesla announces it will open up its US charging network to other car brands, as part of a $7.5 billion federal program to increase the use of EVs and reduce carbon emissions.


May 2023: Setting its price wars with Tesla aside, Ford becomes the first major US automaker to announce that its new EV owners in the US and Canada will be able to use Tesla’s Superchargers starting in spring 2024. Existing Ford EVs like the Mustang Mach-E, F-150 Lightning, and E-Transit can be modified to use Tesla’s Superchargers via an adapter and software integration.


June 2023: GM follows in Ford’s footsteps and adopts Tesla’s NACS as the norm.






By the digits: The charging standards war

17,000: The number of Tesla Supercharger connectors in the US and Canada, compared to...


11,000: ...the number of CCS combo ports in North America.


Half the size, twice as powerful: Tesla’s claims about NACS versus CCS


70%: The share of US EV sales that Tesla, GM, and Ford together account for. That makes NACS more of a “standard” then CCS.


200: The number of miles that can be added to an EV’s range in 15 minutes at a Tesla supercharger station


“Hundred of dollars”: The price range for the adapter that owners of older Ford EVs will require to use Tesla chargers, according to Musk


81,000: The number of fast charging stations using the CCS connector worldwide, compared to...


...45,000: The number of Tesla Superchargers around the world


More than 300: The number of domestic and international members of CharIN North America that are using or investing in CCS


More than 50: The number of passenger vehicle models in the US that use CCS, according to CharIN


$175 (or less): The price of an adapter that lets NACS cars use CCS, suggesting that there’s no big incentive for CCS station managers to add NACS plugs. This, combined with the possibility that NACS adapters for CCS cars will become readily available, would suggest that having two “standards” in the US is possible and maybe even convenient.


Fun fact: Tesla uses CCS

Tesla uses CCS in Europe, in compliance with the global standard.



6 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page