Joni Mitchell & Brene Brown, follow Neil Young out of Spotfy in protest of Joe Rogan
The Bill of Rights isn't half bad. The "freedom of speech" stuff; very OK. Actually better than OK! No? Ask someone who's lived somewhere that doesn't offer such! When Neil Young, Mitchell or Brown try to silence someone simply for allowing listeners to hear contrarian points of view...I wonder if that isn't leaning a wee bit in the direction of tyranny?
I heard Robert Malone's interview on Rogan. Was he interesting? You bet? Do I agree with his point of view? Generally no. I'm an adult with a brain? I can hear opposing points of view and make up my mind.
Is Malone some ignorant crackpot. No, he's the co-inventor of mRNA technology the basis of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines.
Mitchell, Young and Brown have the right to call out Malone and publicly disagree with him. Silence Rogan? Sorry, I don't think that's their right.
Spotify Publishes Content Policy, Covid-19 Hub in Response to Joe Rogan Controversy
CEO Daniel Ek writes, ‘We have an obligation to do more to provide balance and access to widely accepted information’ about the pandemic
Guitarist Nils Lofgren is among the artists who said they have removed their music from the streaming service.
By Anne Steele
Updated Jan. 30, 2022 6:12 pm ET
Music streamer Spotify Technology SA, SPOT 0.97% responding to controversy over its podcaster Joe Rogan, shared its content rules as more artists joined Neil Young in speaking out against Mr. Rogan.
The company on Sunday made public its policies, which it didn’t alter, and created a Covid-19 information hub in response to folk-rocker Neil Young removing his music last week from the streaming service. Mr. Young said he objected to Mr. Rogan and particularly his podcasts about the pandemic and vaccines. His action sparked others, including folk singer Joni Mitchell, to do the same.
“We haven’t been transparent around the policies that guide our content more broadly,” said Chief Executive Daniel Ek in a blog post Sunday. “It’s become clear to me that we have an obligation to do more to provide balance and access to widely accepted information from the medical and scientific communities guiding us through this unprecedented time.”
Spotify isn’t at this time removing any of Mr. Rogan’s episodes that detractors have highlighted in recent weeks as spreading what they deem misinformation about Covid-19 vaccines, said a person familiar with the matter.
Spotify’s platform rules define what it considers to be dangerous, deceptive, sensitive and illegal content. It says creators who break its rules could face consequences including their work being removed.
The steps highlight growing pains for Spotify as it contends with the types of pitched political debates that many large content companies face. It dove into podcasting over the past few years to expand beyond music and become more profitable, and its role as the distributor of popular albeit polarizing voices like Mr. Rogan’s has brought new challenges.
The company’s stance shows it is resolute about keeping its stated commitment to open dialogue, and its lucrative relationship with certain podcasters, while responding to concerns of various creators and customers on which it relies.
“They can have Rogan or Young. Not both,” Mr. Young wrote in a letter he posted on his website last week. Spotify struck a deal with Mr. Rogan in 2020 worth more than $100 million, according to people familiar with the matter.
Over the weekend, Ms. Mitchell and rocker Nils Lofgren joined Mr. Young in seeking to remove their music, they said. Podcaster and professor Brené Brown said she wouldn’t produce more for the service “until further notice,” and the production company of Prince Harry and Meghan, the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, called Archewell Productions, said it has been expressing concerns to Spotify about Covid-19 misinformation on its platform.
“We know we have a critical role to play in supporting creator expression while balancing it with the safety of our users,” said Mr. Ek in the blog post Sunday. “In that role, it is important to me that we don’t take on the position of being content censor while also making sure that there are rules in place and consequences for those who violate them.”
As of Sunday, Spotify is beginning to tag Covid-19-related content with an advisory prompting users to check out the service’s new “hub for data-driven facts and up-to-date information” from the health and scientific communities.
Mr. Young in his initial letter cited an episode of Mr. Rogan’s podcast in which the podcaster spoke with Dr. Robert Malone, a virologist who worked on research into several mRNA Covid-19 vaccines but who is now critical of the treatments. Among the claims made was the suggestion that hospitals have been financially motivated to falsely determine that deaths had been caused by Covid-19.
Earlier this month, a group of 270 scientists and healthcare professionals signed an open letter to Spotify accusing the podcast of “promoting baseless conspiracy theories” and asking the service to take action against mass-misinformation events on its platform.
While more than 40 of Mr. Rogan’s episodes have been previously removed for policy violations, none of them have been related to the pandemic, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Mr. Young has since posted more on the topic, encouraging other artists to join him and steering his listeners to other music streaming platforms.
Keith Tate, a fan of Mr. Young and Ms. Mitchell, canceled his Spotify subscription. The 65-year-old from Houston said his son added him to his YouTube music account. “Works great and Neil Young is there and Joe Rogan is not,” he said.
Mr. Tate owns a company that manufactures high-end basketball equipment, where he hasn’t mandated but encouraged employees to get the Covid-19 vaccines.
“It was amazing how much disinformation there was,” he said. “It took quite a bit of encouragement. I think they all were looking for honest information.”
Mr. Tate said every person in his company is fully vaccinated and boosted now.
Spotify’s Mr. Ek said there are opinions on both sides of any issue and that he personally disagrees with plenty of individuals and views on Spotify.
“To our very core, we believe that listening is everything,” he said.
Dow Jones & Co., publisher of The Wall Street Journal, has a content partnership with Gimlet Media, a unit of Spotify.