Is rent control stupid? Just compare St Paul vs Minneapolis!

And are the two rising stars in the Dem party for rental control (Mamdani and AOC)? Of course they are.

What the Twin Cities Tell Us About Fixing the Housing Crisis

St. Paul enacted rent controls, and housing construction plummeted. Next-door Minneapolis generated a downtown boom without regulating rent.

By Rebecca Picciotto, WSJ

Dec. 15, 2025

Minneapolis made it easier to build apartments instead of turning to rent control. St. Paul’s strict 3% rent-control ordinance led to a 79% drop in apartment-building permits and an at least 6% decline in property values.

ST. PAUL and MINNEAPOLIS, Minn.—Dueling approaches over how to fix America’s housing crisis are splitting Minnesota’s Twin Cities.

In 2022, St. Paul enacted one of the strictest rent-control regimes in the country. The ordinance capped annual rent increases at 3% for most apartments, even empty ones. It didn’t adjust for inflation.

Across the Mississippi River, Minneapolis steered clear of rent control. Instead, city officials strictly focused on creating new housing. A package of land-use revisions in 2020 made it easier to build apartments, in part by removing restrictions that limited housing to single-family homes.

Now, the results are coming into focus. Permits to build apartments in St. Paul plummeted by 79% in early 2022 from the year before, according to data from the Department of Housing and Urban Development. Real-estate investment activity nearly froze. Developers halted new projects as lenders pulled back.

Property values declined as investment cooled. All this compounded the existing real-estate problems brought on by the pandemic.

St. Paul officials are now walking back parts of the ordinance, voting in May to exempt new construction and properties built after 2004. Kaohly Her, the mayor-elect and herself a landlord, campaigned on re-evaluating the rent-control policy further.

“The math just doesn’t work,” she said.

In Minneapolis, meanwhile, developers kept building. Housing permits surged nearly fourfold in early 2022 from the year before. Downtown hubs blossomed as new apartments hit the market and attracted young professionals.

During the pandemic, Minneapolis rents grew more slowly than both St. Paul and the U.S. overall. From 2022 through 2024, Minneapolis rents rose 0.7% on average to $1,506 a month, according to CoStar.

That was lower than the 3.3% national average in those years. In St. Paul, rent growth averaged 1.8% during that time to reach $1,338.

The development boom did less for lower- and middle-income residents, who can’t afford the new housing that is aimed primarily at the higher-end. And rent control became a flashpoint in Minneapolis’s mayoral election when Democratic Socialist candidate Omar Fateh said he would impose such measures.

His pledge echoed the rent-freeze message of New York Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani, who put housing and other affordability issues at the center of his campaign.

But the rent-control pledge didn’t resonate as well in Minneapolis, even as housing costs heat up. Fateh lost in November to the incumbent, Jacob Frey.

“More people are recognizing that rent control doesn’t work,” said Frey.

Rent control gone wrong

The sprawling Highland Bridge development east of the river was one of the first properties to feel the sting of St. Paul’s rent control.

The project was billed as a landmark partnership between city government and the master developer, Ryan Cos. The 122-acre development planned 3,800 units of market-rate and affordable housing, public-park space, and office and retail space.

In 2020, Mayor Melvin Carter donned a construction hat, goggles and vest to tout the project at a virtual groundbreaking ceremony. “We anticipated this day for over a decade,” he said.

Then came rent control. While the subsidized affordable housing and senior housing proceeded, development of the market-rate units at Highland Bridge ground to a halt as private lenders and investors hesitated on financing rent-regulated housing.

“It just puts a mark on the city,” said Maureen Michalski, a senior leader at Ryan Cos.

St. Paul experimented with rent regulation when prices surged nationwide during the pandemic. Developers like Ryan Cos. pushed back, but tenant advocates said that rent control was necessary to ensure lower-income renters wouldn’t be displaced from their neighborhoods.

The stalled Highland Bridge apartments are now moving forward after St. Paul amended the ordinance this spring. Still, the developers say the market-rate apartments are now at least four years behind schedule. They plan to build about 700 fewer units.

“In real estate, time is not a friend,” said Michalski, looking out on the dirt patches where apartment construction should have already started.

Highland Bridge’s market-rate apartments were delayed by St. Paul’s rent-regulation experiment. Drone Brothers

Landlords of older properties, meanwhile, say they are raising rents more often since they are limited to 3% increases.

Alisa Lein, a property manager who lives in St. Paul, used to keep most annual rent increases well below 3%. She raised the price when the apartment turned over. But St. Paul’s ordinance outlawed that practice. Now, she raises rents by the 3% maximum every year.

“Even though I’d love to give someone who’s been in the apartment for 20 years a bit of a break, I can’t anymore,” said Lein.

Other landlords are leaving the market. Joe Hughes, a small owner with 25 buildings across the Twin Cities, said he has sold six St. Paul properties over the past two years. “These brownstones that I’m selling now used to be gems,” he said.

Investment activity also slumped. Since 2022, CBRE found that only two deals have closed in St. Paul for apartment buildings with 100 or more units, compared with dozens in Minneapolis. Property values in St. Paul fell at least 6% because of rent control, a National Bureau of Economic Research study found in 2022.

Those value declines have ripple effects. Landlords often stop upgrading their properties. And with lower values, they pay less in taxes, shifting the burden onto homeowners.

“It was full stop in St. Paul,” said Ari Parritz, a developer in both of the Twin Cities. “People put their pencils down and left.”

On the other side of the river, the North Loop neighborhood in downtown Minneapolis is lit up well past working hours. Streets are lined with high-end apartment buildings, bustling pubs and coffee shops with $8 lattes. The scene is drawing young renters like Aria Burgess.

“I was down here a lot anyway to go out,” said the 23-year-old bartender, who used to rent in a suburb nearby. “It was like, I might as well just move.”

Burgess is comfortable paying $2,200 for her one-bedroom in a luxury building with a rooftop terrace, a hot tub and a bowling alley. Her landlord also offered her a month of free rent to sign the lease.

Still, the new supply has done less for lower-income renters. Eviction filings in Minneapolis were up around 68% from December 2024 to November this year compared with the prepandemic average, according to data from Eviction Lab. They were 61% higher in St. Paul. And as construction costs rise across the country, building in Minneapolis has slowed.

Klyde Warren, a 31-year-old renter in Minneapolis, says rent eats up half of his monthly income, which primarily comes from disability checks. His landlord recently tried to raise his rent by $100, but he negotiated it back down. To him, rent control is a no-brainer.

“St. Paul passed rent control without preparing for it,” said Warren at a recent tenant protest. “But I think it would be a really good measure here.”

Mayor Frey pledges never to implement rent control and has personally written letters to developers assuring as much. The city has expanded subsidies to increase the development of affordable housing but, he added, “Rents rise, inflation rises. Sometimes they rise by too much in a way that hurts people and displaces them.”

Write to Rebecca Picciotto at Rebecca.Picciotto@wsj.com