top of page
Search

Is the ICC about to rule Israel's invasion a genocide?

snitzoid
7 hours ago
6 min read

Iran has attacked the the Saudis, Kutwait & Qatar. Big time. Israel? Of recent, crickets. Few rocket attacks by comparison. Why?


Because the Tribe is happy to turn Tehran into Gaza City. Everybody knows it. That's the only silver lining in a otherwise stupid plan (forgetting the ethics, blowing up Gaza and displacing 2 million folks to live in squalor isn't a great LT plan to further it's strategic interests. It's a great way to hatch future generations of terrorists).


How the Myanmar Genocide Ruling Raises the Stakes for Israel

The most-watched aspect of the case was how the International Court of Justice would determine Myanmar’s intent to commit genocide against the Rohingya

By Feliz Solomon, WSJ

Nov. 20, 2026


Relatives mourn 36-year-old Ramzi Nabil Ramadan Abu Taim in the southern Gaza Strip this month. Abu Taim was killed in an Israeli drone strike. Tariq Mohammad/APA Images/ZUMA Press


The International Court of Justice ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, marking the court’s first such ruling against a state.



TEL AVIV—Until this week, the International Court of Justice had never ruled that a state had intended to commit genocide. That changed with its ruling that Myanmar had perpetrated the crime against the Rohingya—creating a worrying precedent for Israel as it tries to fend off accusations that it, too, pursued a genocide in Gaza.


The most-watched aspect of the case was whether and how the United Nations’ highest court would determine that Myanmar had set out to destroy a group in whole or in part. This bar had never been cleared, giving Israel some comfort that allegations of genocide in Gaza might fall at the same hurdle.


That assumption was shattered in The Hague on Thursday. Now Israel finds itself confronting a court prepared to consider a range of evidence as it weighs whether the totality of its campaign in Gaza, which has left much of the territory in ruins, was carried out with genocidal intent.


“The Israeli government or the Israeli professionals working on the case are going to be more worried, because I think the picture now is less clear as to what exactly the court would factor into its decision,” said Yuval Shany, a senior fellow at the Israel Democracy Institute, a think tank based in Jerusalem.


Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vehemently denied there was a genocide.


While the meaning of genocide might seem clear in cases like mass killing, it can be surprisingly legalistic in court. The Genocide Convention, adopted by the U.N. in 1948 in the wake of the Nuremberg trials of Nazi war criminals, defines it as acts “committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.” Those acts can include killing but also crimes like sexual violence that cause serious mental or physical harm.


But the International Court of Justice, which rules on such cases, has found that committing what it calls “underlying acts” don’t in themselves mean a genocide happened. The key is proof that they were carried out with the specific intent to destroy a protected group.


That special intent, or dolus specialis, has been the hardest part to establish, and the court has two ways to do it. The first is to produce documents or other evidence that explicitly articulates a genocidal plan. Since that is almost never possible, the court can also infer a state’s intent from what they did.


Before this week, the roughly 80-year-old court had only found one instance of genocide, in its 2007 ruling in Bosnia v. Serbia. The court found Serbia failed to prevent genocide in the town of Srebrenica in 1995, but stopped short of holding it directly responsible or finding that genocide occurred in the Yugoslav wars more broadly.


This requirement has frustrated legal scholars, who argue that the bar has been set too high and that genocide should be provable. Others have argued lowering it would undermine the gravity of the crime. It is especially difficult to prove genocidal intent during war, when other motives may be present.


“We have to be able to identify the existence of genocide in the midst of a counterinsurgency campaign or an armed conflict, because if we set up a system that doesn’t enable us to do that, then we’re almost never going to find genocide,” said Rebecca Hamilton, a professor of law at American University in Washington.


Many Israelis fear that in the court of public opinion, their country has already lost.


A July poll by the Associated Press and NORC Center for Public Affairs Research found that 31% of Americans think Israel’s military actions in Gaza amount to genocide, while Pew Research Center surveys show favorable views of Israel have fallen sharply in the U.S.


The mass deaths of civilians, including thousands of women and children, along with the wholesale destruction of the enclave and restrictions on humanitarian aid have hardened views abroad, often amplified by social media. U.N. investigators, human-rights groups such as Amnesty International and aid groups including Doctors Without Borders have all accused Israel of genocide.


Israel acknowledges the destruction but says it was the inevitable consequence of fighting an enemy that attacked it on Oct. 7, 2023, and was embedded in densely-populated civilian communities. The fighting has left more than 70,000 dead, according to Palestinian health authorities, who don’t say how many were combatants.


“It is like this has already been decided and now we need to convince everybody that we didn’t do it, whereas it’s supposed to be the other way around,” said Tammy Caner, director of the Law and National Security program at the Institute for National Security Studies, a think tank based in Tel Aviv.


Caner said the Myanmar judgment was troubling for Israel because it effectively opened the door to a broader interpretation of special intent and granted substantial weight to evidence collected by outside parties such as U.N. fact-finding bodies, which the court can’t always independently corroborate.


The case against Israel is still in its early stages. South Africa brought an accusation against Israel to the International Court of Justice in late 2023. Israel submitted a 1,000-page written response along with 6,000 pages of evidence, a person familiar with the case said. A judgment is still several years away.


The court—which is distinct from the special criminal tribunals set up to rule on the mass killings in Rwanda and former Yugoslavia—has only ever issued judgments on three genocide cases, including Thursday’s ruling. That leaves it little jurisprudence to draw on.


The 2007 Bosnia case set a high bar for proving intent, saying the evidence would have to be such that it could only point to the existence of the intent to destroy a group in whole or in part. The court reaffirmed that in 2015, when it said genocidal intent must be the “only reasonable inference” from the evidence.


Legal scholars have grappled over the language for years. Some interpreted it to mean that the existence of any other intention—such as achieving military objectives—would negate the possibility of genocide. Critics countered that genocides almost always happen in the context of armed conflict.


The court addressed the continuing debate in its judgment against Myanmar on Thursday, saying the presumed intent needs to be the only one that can explain all the evidence. It gave special weight to evidence of sexual violence and harm to Rohingya children because of the impact on the group’s ability to reproduce and survive, and said some patterns of conduct couldn’t be explained by military necessity.


“When some elements of the evidentiary record may allow additional intentions to be inferred, but the totality of the evidence can only be explained by the perpetrator’s genocidal intent, the only reasonable inference standard is met,” the court ruled, finding Myanmar had intended to commit genocide.


Myanmar’s scorched-earth campaign against a small group of poorly armed Rohingya insurgents forced almost the entire population to flee their mostly rural villages for Bangladesh. Israel was fighting against Hamas, a heavily armed U.S.-designated terrorist organization that is entrenched in urban areas.


Israel’s Foreign Ministry has denied the accusation of genocide and said the country acted to defend its citizens by targeting Hamas militants and their accomplices, not Palestinian civilians. South Africa’s argument minimized the role Hamas played in the war, and Israel is confident it will win on the merits of its case, the person familiar with the matter said.


“Israel is not perfect and has made mistakes, which we must acknowledge and take responsibility for,” said Caner at the INSS. “But Israel has never committed genocide.”

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
What percent of NFL Players have CTE?

Study: Estimated 75% of NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE play Shwetha Surendran, ESPN Oct 28, 2026 An estimated 75% of former NFL players who died between 2008 and 2023 had chronic traum

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by The Spritzler Report. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page