Governments certainly have a responsibility to get rid of price fixing, collusion and monopolies. Under short term emergencies, govs have had success in bringing prices back down to earth.
As for the type of sweeping price controls Kamala is proposing? I know zero times in human history where this has worked and to the contrary usually has horrendous unintended consequences. Whether it's rent control that's gone terribly wrong in NYC, Nixon's failed price controls in the 1970s, or a legion of communist regime failures there is no idea that's met with such universal failure.
I'm all for it.
Kamala Harris Wants to Ban Price Gouging. What Do Economists Say?
The line between gouging and normal market forces can be pretty thin. And stopping it is no easy feat either.
By Justin Lahart, WSJ
Aug. 20, 2024 7:00 am ET
Food inflation has eased some recently, but prices still remain much higher than they were before the pandemic. Photo: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg News
Americans hate high prices, and Kamala Harris says she plans to combat them by banning price gouging in food and groceries. But, depending on what form it takes, economists could hate her plan.
Vice President Harris, who will formally accept her party’s nomination at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago this week, has laid the blame for high food prices at the feet of businesses. Surveys conducted by Harvard University economist Stefanie Stantcheva show that many people—Democrats in particular—believe that corporate greed is to blame for inflation.
The food industry has pushed back hard on that belief, arguing that the rise in prices has to do with the extraordinary economic reordering caused by the pandemic, which snarled supply chains, pumped government money into the economy and spiked demand.
GOP candidate Donald Trump, who has frequently complained about high food costs, especially the price of bacon, last week described her plan as “Communist price control.”
Harris’s team has offered few details so far. But here is what economists say about price gouging, what it is, and whether it is ideal—or even possible—to try to curb it.
Why groceries?
While food inflation has eased some recently, prices remain much higher than they were before the pandemic. As of July, consumer prices for food at home were 26% higher than they were at the end of 2019, whereas the prices for goods excluding food and energy items were up just 14%. Food prices hit hard psychologically too—people take frequent trips to the grocery store, and can skimp only so much on what they eat.
Ernie Tedeschi, formerly on the staff at President Biden’s Council of Economic Advisers, now director of economics at the Budget Lab at Yale University, points out that margins at food and beverage retailers have remained elevated relative to before the pandemic, while margins at other retailers, such as clothing and general merchandise stores, haven’t.
That could, he cautions, be a reflection of consumer choice—customers might have changed their preferences to items that are more profitable, such as private-label brands. Regardless, “economists need to be curious about this and figure out what is going on,” Tedeschi said.
2003
'05
'10
'15
'20
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
food and beverage retail
all other retail trade
What is price gouging?
Outside of extreme examples—such as Martin Shkreli raising the price of a decades-old drug used to treat AIDS patients from $13.50 a pill to $750 in 2015—identifying price gouging, and crafting policies against it, can be difficult.
Rules against price-gouging can in effect become price controls. Standard economic theory shows that imposing a price ceiling on a product can discourage sellers, reducing the amount of a product that gets sold, leading to shortages. Rent-control policies are an example of a price ceiling that has become a staple of introductory economics textbooks, and as a group, most economists think rent control is a bad idea.
“It can be very hard to create any price control that is not gameable,” said Michael Sinkinson, an economist at Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management who was also on Biden’s Council of Economic Advisers. “How do you set a price control? What is the right benchmark?”
Does controlling prices ever work?
Economists’ views on rules that prevent price gouging during extreme events, such as severe storms, are more mixed. Such laws are common: During a state of emergency in Florida, for example, it “is unlawful to rent, sell, lease, offer to rent, sell, or lease essential commodities, dwelling units, or self-storage facilities at an unconscionable price.” Shortly after the Covid-19 crisis struck, then-President Trump issued an executive order to prevent price gouging for medical supplies.
Some economists contend that raising prices in these circumstances can be predatory, because supply is limited to whatever businesses have on hand. But others argue that the signal prices send are important: A jump in the price of water at an island that gets hit by a hurricane creates an incentive for water to get shipped in quickly, while an artificially low price during a time of shortage might encourage hoarding.
Kamala Harris has laid the blame for high food prices at the feet of businesses. Photo: Julia Nikhinson/Associated Press
One place economists do accept some degree of price controls is in natural monopolies, points out Harvard economist Greg Mankiw, the author of a widely used introduction to economics textbook and a chair of the Council of Economic Advisers during former President George W. Bush’s administration. Utilities are an example.
But the food business isn’t a monopoly—most people, but not all, have the option of going to another store if one store raises its prices too much. Among economists, said Mankiw, “Our assumption is that firms are always greedy and it is the forces of competition that keeps prices close to cost.”
Harris, for her part, has also said she wants to increase competition.
“My plan will include new penalties for opportunistic companies that exploit crises and break the rules, and we will support smaller food businesses that are trying to play by the rules and get ahead,” she said last week.
The more her plan leans into increasing competition as a way to lower prices, and the less she leans into setting ceilings on prices, the more economists might like what she has to say.
Comments