top of page
Search

Rahm Emanuel Is Betting America Wants a Radical Centrist as President

snitzoid
45 minutes ago
5 min read

He's the full package. A great speaker, quick on his feet, whip smart, reasonable centrist policies.


I realize most people agree he was a lousy Chicago Mayor, but who cares! It's not what you do, it's how you look and.



Rahm Emanuel Is Betting America Wants a Radical Centrist as President

Former Chicago mayor is carving out a middle lane with a focus on corruption and the tax code, rather than the ills of capitalism


By Greg Ip, WSJ

Nov. 16, 2026 5:30 am ET


Economic growth is important. The budget deficit is a serious problem. Bad schools are the biggest threat to the welfare of poor children. Capitalism is mostly good.


These sentiments would strike most Americans as pretty sensible, yet were hardly central in Democrats’ messaging on their way to a historic midterm election win two weeks ago.


Which is why it is noteworthy that all are reflected in a speech that former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, a fixture of Democratic politics for three decades, plans to deliver today.


“A wing of my party thinks the problem with capitalism is capitalism,” he says in remarks to be delivered at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh.


“They’re wrong,” he said. The problem is “rampant corruption in our politics, in our economy, and in our tax code, which adds up to intolerable inequality.”


Emanuel is thinking of running for president, and his speech is the de facto economic platform of that as-yet-unannounced campaign.


By any measure he would be an underdog; Kalshi puts the probability of him winning the presidential primary at 2%, in 14th place.


But he is already a force in the “ideas primary” that will help shape what the party stands for in 2028.


The midterms didn’t really settle the question. They were more of a referendum on President Trump than an endorsement of Democrats. Candidates coalesced around a few common economic themes: raise the federal minimum wage, repeal tariffs, restore Obamacare subsidies, all of which Emanuel endorses.


The real battle is between progressives pushing more radical solutions and moderates who want to hold on to the independents and persuadable Republicans who made their majorities possible.


Emanuel identifies firmly with the latter. He was an adviser to both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama and in between led Democrats’ 2006 successful campaign to retake the House of Representatives. In a party that has drifted leftward since, he is a radical centrist.


US President Barack Obama shakes hands with outgoing White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel.

Emanuel with then-President Barack Obama in 2010. Yuri Gripas/AFP/via Getty Images

In his speech, Emanuel faults many in his own party for taking the wrong lessons from Trump’s presidency.


“Under Trump, the GOP went from a party dedicated to the free market to one defined by the corruption of crony capitalism. …The Democrats have allowed Trump to occupy so much of our brain that we have become intellectually lazy and politically timid. We’ve spent so much time arguing over how to divide the pie that we forgot how to grow it.”


Emanuel elaborated on this in an interview last week: “There are more choices than either the crony capitalism and the corruption on one side and redistribution for the sake of redistribution on the other.”


In the interview, Emanuel was unsparing in his criticism of business behavior under Trump. “I’m appalled at what a bunch of phonies they are. You know that capitalism is built on the rule of law and you are willing to let it go for the rule of one. You participated willingly in a pay-to-play culture.”


Emanuel says capitalism needs “fundamental reform,” although his fixes sound more incremental: ban stock trading by, and foreign gifts and investments to, public officials; curb the ability of the rich to pass on wealth tax-free; close loopholes that benefit hedge funds and foreign profits; raise the tax rate on capital gains and corporate profits.


Where Emanuel becomes truly passionate is education. Here again he faults fellow Democrats. “I don’t think a party can believe in equity as a core principle and be comfortable with 50% of our kids not reading at grade level. And not just comfortable, silent about it,” he told me.


In his speech, he touts his record running Chicago from 2011 to 2019: lengthening the school day and year, adding universal pre-K and full-day kindergarten, and a notable rise in graduation rates and test scores. He mandated that to obtain their high-school diploma, every student present a letter of acceptance from a two- or four-year college, the armed forces or a vocational school.


He’d like to take similar steps nationwide. A student absent more than 7% of the year wouldn’t graduate. Every high-school student would earn some college credit.


Emanuel stands apart from other Democrats in another way: his readiness to credit Republicans. He lauds the education progress in Mississippi and especially Louisiana, the only state where fourth-grade math and reading scores have surpassed prepandemic levels.


His recent visit to Louisiana impressed one of its Republican senators, John Kennedy: “While many members of his own party want to sit around and debate whether a man can breast feed, Rahm wants to talk about important things like education,” he told NBC News.


But can he be president?

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Rep. Rahm Emanuel applaud with other representatives during a news conference.

Then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Emanuel in 2007. Susan Walsh/AP

Why would an aspiring Democratic presidential nominee say unkind things about Democrats and nice things about Republicans? One theory is that voters want a candidate to prove he’ll put the country ahead of his allies. John F. Kennedy said he would govern according to the national interest, not his Catholicism; Clinton and Obama distanced themselves from some allies’ racially polarizing remarks.


Emanuel has taken plenty of incoming from his own party. Chicago suffered its first teachers’ strike in 25 years over his efforts to tie teacher pay more closely to performance. Several Democratic senators voted against his nomination to be President Joe Biden’s ambassador to Japan over a controversial shooting by Chicago police of a Black teenager (for which he had apologized).


Of course, that also means Emanuel has alienated core constituencies whose support will count in the 2028 primaries. That would matter less if he were the lone moderate in the race. But the moderate lane could get crowded, especially since several centrists in the midterms recorded landslide victories in battleground states, such as Jon Ossoff, re-elected senator in Georgia, and Josh Shapiro, re-elected governor in Pennsylvania.


But many moderate Democrats would welcome Emanuel’s presence regardless of his chances. Jim Kessler, executive vice president of the centrist group Third Way, said, “He’s a font of ideas. He’s completely fearless. And he’s not desperately trying to be liked. That’s his superpower. And I think he’s going to be a provocateur from the center, tearing progressive plans to shreds because they are so half-baked.”


For his part, Emanuel told me his ideas are aimed at the country, not his party. “The right fears me and the far left reviles me. I am right where I want to be and where the country is.”

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Snitz mansplains how to get a job!

Never, I repeat never let the facts get in the way of a good story. Always wish you had worked in consulting and had an advanced degree from an Ivy. BAM, you're now an alum of McKinsey and the Wharton

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by The Spritzler Report. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page