top of page
Search

The FAA Is a Classic Government Failure? Haha!

snitzoid
9 hours ago
3 min read

I had an epiphany this morning. The socialists are right. Let's allow the government to run everything. Imagine all aspects of your life run like the FAA!


The FAA Is a Classic Government Failure

Travel woes will persist until Congress reforms the air-traffic system.

By The Editorial Board, WSJ

Updated Nov. 15, 2026 9:05 pm ET


And you thought flying in America couldn’t get worse. Then on Friday more than 12,000 flights were canceled after the Federal Aviation Administration ordered an extraordinary nationwide ground stop that lasted more than four hours. Was there a terrorist threat? Cyber-attack? No, the cause appears to have been routine government failure.


Friday’s fiasco, which disrupted millions of travel plans, laid bare the myriad dysfunctions of America’s government-run air-traffic control system that have led to repeated system failures and delays. Flyers were left stranded for hours as the FAA tried to diagnose and fix the problem, which officials eventually tied to a new router at a facility in Arkansas.


According to FAA officials, the router along with another one in Texas flooded its communications system with data. It’s far from reassuring that one or two malfunctioning devices can take down continental air traffic. Or that the Sherlock Holmeses at the FAA still aren’t sure exactly what went wrong.


Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blamed either a faulty device or “incompetence” by the contractor L3Harris Technologies that had installed it. HPE, the router manufacturer, said its hardware “did not fail.” While Mr. Duffy claimed the government hasn’t found evidence of nefarious causes, it’s understandable to wonder given that adversaries are stepping up cyberattacks across the U.S. economy and government.


As is their habit, politicians rushed to capitalize on the public misery. Democrats blamed the Administration’s new SMART system, which uses AI to analyze airline schedules, weather, airspace conditions, among other things, to prevent flight conflicts that cause delays. There’s no evidence the AI system contributed to Friday’s problems.


Mr. Duffy on Thursday called for $30 billion in more funding, on top of the $12.5 billion Republicans appropriated in last year’s tax bill. After Friday’s failure, he raised the demand to $50 billion. But throwing more money at an unaccountable agency will at best be a temporary fix and will reward dysfunction.


In 2003 Congress directed the FAA to modernize America’s aging air-traffic system, yet the Government Accountability Office reported in September that the FAA doesn’t plan to complete the first phase of upgrades until December 2028. That’s a quarter-century.


The GAO also said the FAA lacks a reliable estimate for when the second phase will be done and how much the entire project will cost. This is government incompetence across several administrations at a California bullet-train-to-nowhere level. Criticism from Pete Buttigieg, the Biden transportation secretary, is especially laughable given his obvious failure to improve things over four years in the job. And he apparently wants to run for President again.


Republican leaders this weekend nonetheless said they will include more money in a lame-duck reconciliation bill. Keep in mind that most of the $30 billion in the Modern Skies Act, which the Administration has backed, wouldn’t even fund air-traffic control. Most would fund airport terminal improvements that are typically paid for by localities.


A source says it includes earmarks that would benefit airports in St. Louis, Mo., the state of the bill’s GOP Senate sponsor Eric Schmitt, and Palm Beach near President Trump’s Mar-a-Lago club. This underscores the problem with the current system controlled by politicians and dominated by special interests.


Long-term upgrades are hostage to annual Congressional appropriations. Government unions and lawmakers obstruct investments and reforms to improve efficiency. United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby last week said he thought privatizing air-traffic control could get upgrades “done in two to three years.” No less than Al Gore championed reform in the 1990s.


Yet private jet operators and unions blocked GOP legislation during the first Trump Administration to follow Canada’s example and turn the system over to a nonprofit to run. (See Marc Scribner’s persuasive analysis nearby.) Republicans appear to have given up on even pushing the idea. Expect flying headaches to continue as long as government won’t give up political control of the skies, despite its manifest and growing failures.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Are megacities still growing? Most outside the US?

I had Claude look at the analysis by the World Population Review. A little more context to give you the big picture. These charts show where city growth is concentrated today: South Asia and Sub-Sahar

 
 
 
Do I want Meta or Google Smart Glasses?

I'm not an early adopter here. I'm waiting till they have Xray vision. Oh, wait a minute...no that's very wrong. I'm sticking with my Walmart readers. Less chance of getting myself banned.

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by The Spritzler Report. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page