top of page
Search

How much safer is Waymo than a human driver?

snitzoid
1 day ago
3 min read

The Waymo is way safer. Hey that sort of rhymes! Maybe even the tag line for a national campaign?



Based on large-scale real-world mileage datasets—including Waymo’s safety impact dataset covering 271.3 million rider-only miles (reported under NHTSA's Standing General Order), independent actuarial research by Swiss Re (25.3 million miles), and studies by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS)—autonomous Waymo vehicles experience substantially lower crash, injury, and liability claim rates than human-driven vehicles operating in the same cities.

1. Overall Crash & Severity Rates

Because autonomous vehicles are required to report even minor, low-speed contact events (such as a vehicle brushing a stationary object at <1 mph) that humans rarely report to police, traffic safety researchers focus on injury-causing crashes and airbag deployments to make apples-to-apples comparisons.

Safety Metric (Per Million Miles)

Human Driver Benchmark

Waymo Rider-Only

Net Reduction

Estimated Incidents Prevented (over 271.3M mi)

Any-Injury-Reported Crashes

3.77 IPMM

0.67 IPMM

-82%

~841 fewer injury crashes

Airbag Deployment (Any Vehicle)

1.61 IPMM

0.29 IPMM

-82%

~357–358 fewer crashes

Airbag Deployment (Subject Vehicle)

1.06 IPMM

0.05 IPMM

-95%

—

Serious Injury or Worse Crashes

0.21 IPMM

0.01 IPMM

-95%

~55 fewer severe crashes

  • IIHS Overall Crash Analysis: Independent IIHS research filtering out non-public-road and non-crash anomalies found that Waymo's overall crash rate is 68% lower than human drivers across comparable urban driving conditions.

  • Fault & Third-Party Collisions: In the Swiss Re insurance claims study (which measures at-fault liability claims paid out to other drivers, cyclists, or pedestrians), Waymo recorded 88% fewer property damage claims and 92% fewer bodily injury claims than the general human driving population—and 86% to 90% fewer claims even when compared strictly against newer human-driven vehicles equipped with Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) like automatic emergency braking and blind-spot monitoring. Furthermore, a large share of Waymo's recorded collisions involve human drivers rear-ending or sideswiping a stopped or law-abiding Waymo vehicle.

2. Risk to Cyclists, Pedestrians, and Other Drivers

Because Waymo uses a 360-degree sensor suite (LiDAR, radar, and high-resolution cameras) that eliminates blind spots, distraction, fatigue, and impairment, its largest safety margins appear in protecting vulnerable road users:

  • Cyclists: 86% reduction in injury-causing crashes compared to human drivers over the same mileage in the same cities (56 fewer injury crashes across 271.3 million miles).

  • Pedestrians: 93% reduction in injury-causing crashes (87 fewer injury crashes).

  • Motorcyclists: 82% reduction in injury-causing crashes (36 fewer injury crashes).

  • Other Motorists: Across vehicle-to-vehicle collisions, Waymo reduces intersection-related injury crashes and high-speed impacts substantially; roughly 41% of all Waymo collisions involve a velocity change ($\Delta v$) of less than 1 mph.

3. Visual Comparison: Crash Rates & Percentage Reductions

Here is a visual breakdown of the per-million-mile incident rates alongside the percentage reductions across road user groups and insurance liability claims:

Important Context & Caveats

  1. Geographic & Weather Scope: Human crash benchmarks in these studies are calibrated specifically to the dense urban and suburban territories where Waymo operates (such as San Francisco, Phoenix, Los Angeles, Austin, and Atlanta). While urban streets have higher pedestrian and cyclist density than rural highways, Waymo also operates less frequently in extreme winter weather (heavy snow or ice) than the broader national human driving fleet.

  2. Reporting Asymmetry: NHTSA estimates that roughly 60% of property-damage-only crashes and 32% of injury crashes involving human drivers go unreported to police. Waymo reports virtually every contact event automatically via telemetry, meaning raw "any-contact" counts favor humans unless adjusted for severity or underreporting.

  3. Edge-Case Behaviors: While Waymo excels at avoiding high-energy collisions, speeding, and distracted driving, safety regulators and researchers continue to monitor lower-severity edge cases—such as sudden braking ("phantom braking"), blocking emergency lanes, or navigating complex construction zones and erratic human traffic.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
What percent of NFL Players have CTE?

Study: Estimated 75% of NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE play Shwetha Surendran, ESPN Oct 28, 2026 An estimated 75% of former NFL players who died between 2008 and 2023 had chronic traum

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by The Spritzler Report. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page