top of page
Search

Mamdani’s ‘close Rikers’ plan would put more than 1,000 violent criminals back on the streets

snitzoid
8 hours ago
3 min read

To indict someone simply because they're a violent sociopath is inhuman. Father Flanagan was right "There is no such thing as a bad boy". Don't condemn me because I choose to exercise my 2nd amendment rights.


Hey wait a minute, I don't own a gun. Dagnabbit.



Mamdani’s ‘close Rikers’ plan would put more than 1,000 violent criminals back on the streets

By Jim Quinn, NY Post

Published Nov. 20, 2026


Mayor Mamdani doubled down Friday on the city’s plan to close Rikers Island, building instead a totally inadequate 4,100 borough-based jail cells for a city with a population of 8.5 million and almost 500,000 reported crimes a year.


His plan to reduce the city’s jail population contains all the usual progressive talking points that have been bandied about for the past 10 years: Speed up case processing, more alternative-to-incarceration programs, easier access to bail.


He acts as if none of these has been tried before, when in fact every one of them has.


But missing from the mayor’s press release is any analysis of who is on Rikers today.


So here is the truth.


There are currently 6,640 inmates on Rikers.


There’s not much the city can do to release them earlier.


That means if the borough-based jails were today’s reality, we’d have about 3,000 available beds for the 5,606 defendants awaiting trial.


Rikers Island by the numbers:

  • Inmates currently in Rikers Island: 6,640

  • Have already been sentenced and are awaiting transfer to other prisons: 1,100

  • Are charged with murder: 1,433

  • Are charged with a violent felony offense such as attempted murder or rape: 2,625

  • Total number of inmates sentenced or charged with a serious crime: 5,158

  • Borough jail capacity under the plan to close Rikers: 4,100

  • Number of serious offenders who would have to be freed under Mamdani’s plan: 1,058

  • Of those awaiting trial today, 1,433 are charged with murder; 2,625 are charged with a violent felony offense (such as attempted murder, robbery, burglary, rape, weapons possession or assault).


That’s 4,058 inmates — enough to fill every one of the 4,100 “neighborhood jail” beds the city is building.


But with only 3,000 of those beds available, about 1,000 defendants charged with murder or violent felonies will have to be released.


And that leaves no room at all in the new jails for the current population of 1,282 non-violent felon inmates (car thieves, pocketbook snatchers, commercial burglars, drug dealers and fraudsters), and 269 misdemeanor inmates (like shoplifters and petty thieves).


Every one of them would need to be released so that the city can accommodate accused murderers, violent felons and non pre-trial detainees in those 4,100 jail beds.


These non-violent felon and misdemeanor detainees are not first-time offenders.


Under the bail reform laws passed in 2019 and amended since, a “non-violent” felon or misdemeanor defendant can only have bail set if they’ve committed a crime while out on probation or parole, or have two or more prior felony convictions, or harmed someone while on release for a pending charge of harming someone else.


Even then, they’ve had to be unlucky enough to have been arraigned before one of the few NYC judges who sets bail at all.



That is the pool of people Mamdani is looking to put back out on the streets.


The mayor is not being honest with New York.


Caught up in the anti-Rikers hysteria of 10 years ago, he and his allies believed the hype and ignored the consequences.


Under the 2019 bail reform, the city released thousands of career “non-violent” criminals from jail — and non-violent crime went up.


When COVID hit, the city released hundreds of violent criminals from jail — and violent crime went up.


Crime today is still 20% higher than pre-bail reform.


Now Mamdani and his allies are pushing a severely broken city court system to speed up cases in order to reduce the jail population by 800 beds.


Consider: Since 2019, the number of criminal cases pending in NYC rose by 13,253 cases, or 41%. The entire rest of New York state rose by only 862 cases.


Speedy-trial dismissals rose 620% in NYC, from 8,282 to 59,572, since 2019; outside NYC, the rise was 75%.


The collapse of the criminal court system in NYC is unique.


The courts have had 10 years to fix that. They haven’t. They can’t.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
What percent of NFL Players have CTE?

Study: Estimated 75% of NFL players who died from 2008 to 2023 had CTE play Shwetha Surendran, ESPN Oct 28, 2026 An estimated 75% of former NFL players who died between 2008 and 2023 had chronic traum

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by The Spritzler Report. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page