What are the College Rankings, if you remove politics?
Since the WSJ apparently didn't have the brains to share the data, I took the liberty of including the actual list (top 20) from the Manhattan Institute's study below (after the article).
Your welcome!
College Rankings, Minus the Politics
A new rating factors in ideological diversity and campus free speech. No. 1? Texas at Austin.
By The Editorial Board
Nov. 13, 2026 5:37 pm ET
The campus of Yale University in New Haven, Conn. Jessica Hill/Associated Press
Choosing a college is a daunting task for students and parents, and political polarization hasn’t made it easier. These days a university might get a high ranking for academics and facilities, despite being a hot house of progressive conformity. How are parents supposed to know?
The Manhattan Institute’s publication City Journal aims to fill the information gap, and this week it posted its second annual college ranking, covering 115 name brand schools, public and private. The list is based on 95 variables, including the basics, such as graduation rates and earnings after enrollment. But it also awards points for indicators of ideological diversity, free speech, and emphasis on academic merit rather than identity politics.
Does the college require students to take a class on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI)? How about a course in U.S. government or history? Is a standardized test score required on applications? Does the school have a “bias reporting system”? How monolithic are faculty campaign donations? Do job ads ask for a DEI statement? Does the school do “land acknowledgments”? The ranking factors in these questions and more, and see its methodology section for details.
The University of Texas at Austin is on top this year, followed by the University of Florida at No. 2. Both have recently set up new “civics schools”—the School of Civic Leadership in Texas and the Hamilton School in Florida—to promote civil discourse and liberal arts in the Western tradition. Rounding out the top five on the City Journal ranking are Notre Dame, MIT and Claremont McKenna.
Last year’s ranking used fewer metrics, but it’s notable that some Ivy League schools moved up this year, including Yale (No. 10 from 30), Harvard (19 from 37), and Dartmouth (27 from 57). All three are reinstating standardized tests. “Yale has also prohibited diversity statements in faculty hiring,” City Journal says. It gets demerits, however, for merely rebranding campus DEI efforts rather than dismantling them, and the report says Yale’s identity-based “cultural centers” have “2.2 employees per 1,000 undergraduates—higher than our average of 1.5.”
One useful effect of these ranking is to let college administrators know that backsliding will be noticed, given that reforms to higher education can be precarious. The Texas Legislature dismantled DEI programs at public universities, but after last week’s midterms that is in jeopardy. The Ivies are under reform pressure from the Trump Administration, but a Democratic President would end that.
Meantime, there’s room to improve, including in places that might surprise. Why is Indiana University-Bloomington No. 58? “For starters, its administration is deeply devoted to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion,” City Journal says. “The school requires students to take DEI-focused classes to graduate but does not require coursework in more academically relevant subjects, such as history or government.”
Rigorous academic institutions that respect Western values are an American strength and good for civic health. College rankings that include this as a measure of success are a useful service. Policy makers can check if their reforms are falling behind, while prospective students can find a college where they can learn and debate without being shouted down by a campus mob.
Snitz pulls actual list from the Manhattan Institute's study
Complete Top 20 Breakdown
Rank | Institution | Score (out of 100) | Notable Strengths in the 2026 Report |
1 | The University of Texas at Austin | 79.7 | |
2 | University of Florida | 78.1 | |
3 | University of Notre Dame | 75.7 | #1 overall in student life & student ideological pluralism; top 10 in post-grad outcomes |
4 | Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) | 72.2 | |
5 (tie) | Claremont McKenna College | 71.4 | |
5 (tie) | University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill | 71.4 | |
7 | Georgia Institute of Technology | 70.3 | |
8 | Purdue University | 67.7 | #1 in institutional management/governance; strong ROI and meritocracy |
9 | Ohio State University | 67.4 | Top-10 finish ahead of traditional Ivy League peers |
10 | Yale University | 66.5 | Highest-ranked Ivy League institution; #4 in presidential rhetorical leadership |
11 | Florida State University | 65.9 | #3 in governance/institutional management; top 10 in educational quality |
12 | Texas A&M University | 65.8 | |
13 | Arizona State University | 65.4 | #4 overall in educational quality |
14 | Vanderbilt University | 64.8 | #1 in resistance to politicization and presidential rhetorical leadership |
15 | Princeton University | 64.5 | #4 overall in post-graduation outcomes and educational payback |
16 | Stanford University | 63.6 | #3 overall in post-graduation career and earnings outcomes |
17 | Clemson University | 63.4 | |
18 | California Institute of Technology (Caltech) | 63.2 | #5 overall in career and educational outcomes |
19 | Harvard University | 62.6 | |
20 | ~62.1–62.5 | Note: #21 University of Iowa scored 62.0 (#5 in student ideological pluralism) |
Comments